La Villemarque's Barzaz-Breiz (1839–1845–1867): A Romantic Fiction to Reinvent Oneself
Nelly Blanchard
Univ Brest, CRBC, Brest, France
Abstract
In 1839, Viscount Théodore Hersart de La Villemarqué published the Barzaz-Breiz (The Popular Ballads of Brittany) at his own expense. He was only 24 years old at the time. This book would bring him fame, give him a name and was to influence all of his future work. The Barzaz-Breiz was then further developed and modified twice afterwards, in 1845 and 1867. To this day it remains one of the best known books in Breton language literature.
There are several reasons why the Barzaz-Breiz should not be reduced to just a collection of popular ballads as its title and research on the subject suggest. First of all, the authenticity of the songs of the Barzaz-Breiz and their possible modification, manipulation — or even their total invention by de la Villemarqué — have been the object of so much scholarly debate since the beginning of what came to be called the Barzaz-Breiz dispute, that attention has almost exclusively been focused on the ballads, leaving the rest of the text in the shadows. Secondly, there is a yawning chasm separating La Villemarqué’s work from that of his contemporaries who also collected popular songs. The book forms a space which is made up of de la Villemarqué’s words and serves as the locus for his reallocation of meanings to words. What we are given to read here is no less than a dissertation about the author himself. This paper therefore posits that the Barzaz-Breiz is not a mere collection of popular songs but rather a text — de la Villemarqué is not a mere collector but an author.
Studia Celto-Slavica 13: 85–100 (2023)
-
References
Augustin, T., 1825, Histoire de la conquête de l’Angleterre par les Normands, Paris: Garnier Frères.
Blanchard, N., 2006, Barzaz-Breiz. Une fiction pour s’ inventer, Rennes: PUR. https://doi.org/10.4000/books.pur.32655
Cachin, F., 1997, ‘Le paysage du peintre’, in: Nora, P., ed., Les Lieux de mémoire, Paris: Quarto Gallimard, vol. I, 957–96.
Chateaubriand, de, F.-R., 1981, ‘Essai sur les révolutions’, in: Michel, P. , ed., Un mythe romantique. Les Barbares, 1789–1848, Lyon: PUL.
Gourvil, F., 1960, Théodore-Claude-Henri Hersart de La Villemarqué (1815–1895) et le «Barzaz-Breiz» (1839–1845–1867), Rennes: Origine-Éditions-Sources-Critique-Influences, Oberthur.
Herder, J. G., 1784–1791, Ideen zur Philosophieder Geschichte der Menschheit, Riga-Leipzig: Hartknoch.
Julliard, J., 1997, ‘Le peuple’, in: Nora, P., ed., Les Lieux de mémoire, Paris: Quarto Gallimard, 103–10.
Laurent, D., 1989, Aux sources du Barzaz-Breiz. La mémoire d’un peuple, Douarnenez: Ar Men.
Laurent, D., 1974, La Villemarqué collecteur de chants populaires: étude des sources du premier Barzaz-Breiz à partir des originaux de collecte (1833–1840), PhD thesis, Paris Sorbonne University.
La Villemarqué, de, T. H., 1839, Barzas-Breiz. Chants populaires de la Bretagne, recueillis et publiés avec une traduction française, des éclaircissements, des notes et les mélodies originales, Paris: Charpentier.
La Villemarqué, de, T. H., 1845, Barzaz-Breiz. Chants populaires de la Bretagne recueillis et publiés avec une Traduction française, des Arguments, des Notes et les mélodies originales, 3rd edition, Paris: Delloye.
La Villemarqué, de, T. H., 1867, Barzaz-Breiz. Chants populaires de la Bretagne, 6th edition, Paris: Librairie Académique Didier et Cie.
Maunoir, J. (Révérend Père), 1659, Sacré collège de Jésus, Quimper: Jean Hardouyn.
Nora, P., 1997, Les Lieux de mémoire, Paris: Quarto Gallimard.
Plötner-Le Lay, B., 2007, Émile Souvestre, 1806–1854, écrivain breton porté par l’utopie sociale, Brest: CRBC.
Rousseau, J.-J., 1992, Émile ou De l’éducation, Paris: Bordas.
Souvestre, E., 1836, Les Derniers Bretons, Paris: Charpentier.
Souvestre, E., 1844, Le Foyer breton. Contes et récits populaires, Paris: W. Coquebert.
Vico, G., 1725–1744, La Scienzanuova, Napoli: Muziana.